Kitty Hawk may not have as many dedicated oyster bars as some neighboring Outer Banks towns, but several spots serve fresh, well-prepared oysters worth seeking out. Here’s a focused roundup of the top options from the PhillyBite restaurant list, with Two Roads Tavern leading the pack for variety and creativity.
Two Roads Tavern
3833 N Croatan Highway
The clear standout for oysters in Kitty Hawk. This welcoming tavern specializes in unique preparations: Oysters Kitty Hawk (char-grilled with parsley, lime, cheeses, and Tabasco garlic butter), Kill Devil Hills (baked with prosciutto, shallots, and Parmesan), Nags Head (spinach, bacon, garlic, and panko), plus fried oysters, raw, and the Outer Banks sampler flight. Reviewers consistently praise the fresh oysters and creative styles. Pair them with cold drinks in a relaxed tavern setting—highly recommended as the top pick.
The Black Pelican Oceanfront Restaurant
3848 N Virginia Dare Trail
Historic oceanfront restaurant that regularly appears on best-oysters lists for Kitty Hawk. Expect fresh seafood including solid oyster options alongside wood-fired pizza and other coastal favorites. The ocean views and setting elevate the experience—great when you want oysters with scenery.
Hurricane Mo’s Beachside Bar And Grill
120 E Kitty Hawk Road
Beachside spot known for tropical vibes and strong seafood (including fantastic blackened tuna). Oysters feature on the menu in this lively, flavorful environment—ideal if you want oysters as part of a fun, energetic meal close to the beach.
Shipwrecks Taphouse & Grill
4020 N Croatan Highway
Lively taphouse with a solid seafood selection that includes oysters among its burgers, sandwiches, and steamed options. The covered patio and casual vibe make it a good place to enjoy oysters with a cold draft beer.
Other notes: Places like Barefoot Bernie’s and Jimmy’s Seafood Buffet offer broader seafood menus that may include oysters depending on the day and season. For the most dedicated oyster experience within this list, start at Two Roads Tavern.
Tips: Oyster availability and preparations can change with the season and supply—call ahead if you have a specific style in mind. Many of these spots pair oysters well with cold drinks and outdoor seating. Enjoy the fresh Outer Banks catch!
Follow Us!