NEW JERSEY – Cape May, a charming coastal town in New Jersey, is a haven for food enthusiasts, offering diverse dining experiences to tantalize your taste buds. From fresh seafood to Italian delicacies and upscale fine dining to casual beachside eateries, Cape May’s culinary scene has something for everyone. Let’s embark on a gastronomic adventure and explore 25 of the best restaurants this enchanting town offers.
Smoked Pork Belly
A Culinary Journey Through Cape May: 25 Must-Try Restaurants
Fine Dining and Upscale Eateries
Peter Shields Inn: Nestled in a 1907 mansion, this upscale eatery exudes a fun and laid-back vibe while serving American dishes with a focus on small plates and burgers.
Aleathea’s Restaurant: Immerse yourself in the elegance of this Victorian Inn, where you can savor upscale American cuisine with a breathtaking view of the harbor.
Washington Inn & Wine Bar: Indulge in fine dining at this historic inn, featuring six unique dining areas, including a charming outdoor patio and a cozy fireside nook.
Shamone BYOB: Elevate your dining experience at this upscale tapas restaurant within a bustling mall. Bring your own wine and enjoy a multi-course culinary journey.
Casual Dining and Waterfront Gems
Lucky Bones Back Water Grille: This waterfront restaurant offers three distinct atmospheres: a pizzeria, a dining room, and a bar, making it perfect for any occasion.
The Blue Pig Tavern: Located in the famous Congress Hall Hotel, this tavern serves classic American fare, focusing on seasonal ingredients and fresh seafood.
The Pier House: With a beach-chic ambiance and stunning ocean views, this restaurant is ideal for enjoying locally sourced, seasonal dishes.
Brine: Situated on the waterfront at the South Jersey Marina, this casual eatery offers classic American breakfast and lunch dishes with a creative twist.
The Lobster House: A Cape May institution on Fisherman’s Wharf is a seafood lover’s paradise, offering fresh catches and a lively atmosphere.
International Flavors and BYOB Options
George’s Place: Transport your taste buds to Greece at this lively tavern, where you can enjoy fresh Greek cuisine and watch the sunset over the Atlantic.
Sapore Italiano: Housed in a Victorian home, this charming restaurant serves Italian-inspired cuisine, focusing on local ingredients and gluten-free options.
Viggiano’s on Sunset: Savor authentic Italian flavors at this pizzeria and pasta haven, recently recognized as one of New Jersey’s best new restaurants.
Iccara Italian Bistro: This cozy Sicilian eatery offers seafood specialties, steaks, and kid-friendly fare, along with an enticing early bird special.
Vintage BYOB: Located on the Emlen Physick Estate, this casual spot offers a unique and creative menu in a relaxed setting.
Local Favorites and Hidden Gems
410 Bank Street Restaurant: With fifteen years of experience, this restaurant continues to impress under new management, serving exceptional dishes with impeccable service.
Black Duck On Sunset: Enjoy moderately priced breakfast and lunch items at this West Cape May establishment, known for its quality coffee and catering services.
Louisa’s Cafe: Experience the farm-to-table philosophy at this long-standing café, where fresh, local ingredients take center stage.
The Mad Batter Restaurant & Bar: This lively spot in historic downtown Cape May offers American cuisine, live music, and a fun atmosphere for a night out.
Tisha’s Fine Dining: This quaint eatery serves modern New American fare in a charming setting, perfect for a romantic dinner or dinner with friends.
Cape May Fish Market: A must-visit for seafood lovers, this market offers fresh catches and well-seasoned dishes in a comfortable setting with outdoor tables.
Quincy’s Original Lobster Rolls: Indulge in classic Maine and Connecticut-style lobster rolls at this famous seafood chain with multiple locations along the Jersey Shore.
Oyster Bay Restaurant & Bar: This off-the-beaten-path restaurant offers fresh seafood, steak, and pub fare, along with a full bar featuring local wines and craft beers.
H&H Seafood Market: This market is the perfect spot for affordable fresh seafood, offering everything from buckets of crab and lobster to various other options.
No matter your culinary preferences or budget, Cape May’s diverse dining scene is sure to satisfy. From elegant waterfront establishments to casual, family-friendly spots, this charming town invites you to embark on a culinary adventure you will never forget.
Follow Us!