NEW JERSEY – Haddonfield residents and bagel lovers, get ready! After nearly a year of anticipation, Penny’s Bagels, the new venture from acclaimed Philadelphia hospitality duo Chris Fetfatzes and Heather Annechiarico, is making significant strides towards opening its doors. With secured construction permits and previous zoning and health approvals in place, the team targets a late Spring 2025 debut, potentially bringing fresh-baked bagel bliss to Haddonfield by Memorial Day weekend.
From Philly Success to Haddonfield Expansion
Chris Fetfatzes and Heather Annechiarico are well-known figures in Philadelphia’s vibrant food and drink scene. They are the driving force behind popular establishments like Hawthorne’s, Grace & Proper, and the recently revived Sonny’s Cocktail Joint. Their track record of creating successful neighborhood spots has generated considerable excitement for Penny’s Bagels, their first venture into Haddonfield.
Location and Transformation:
Penny’s Bagels will be located at 212 Kings Highway East, taking over the space previously occupied by the women’s clothing store, Lunachick. While the storefront requires significant work, including plumbing and electrical renovations, ownership is optimistic about the progress. The transformation promises to breathe new life into this prime downtown Haddonfield location.
What to Expect: Fresh Bagels and Classic Pairings:
Future patrons can look forward to the simple, satisfying pleasures of a classic bagel shop experience. Penny’s will focus on:
- Fresh Bagels: Baked on-site daily.
- Smoked Fish: Offering traditional accompaniments.
- Coffee: Providing the perfect brew to pair with your bagel.
Anticipation Builds for Spring Opening:
Although the opening is later than originally anticipated, the recent acquisition of construction permits marks a major step forward. The team is now aiming for a late Spring 2025 opening, with Memorial Day (May 26th, 2025) as a target debut date.
Conclusion:
The arrival of Penny’s Bagels is eagerly awaited in Haddonfield. With experienced and successful restaurateurs Chris Fetfatzes and Heather Annechiarico at the helm, and the promise of fresh, on-site baked bagels, smoked fish, and coffee, Penny’s is poised to become a beloved addition to the borough’s thriving downtown scene. Keep an eye out for progress at 212 Kings Highway East as Haddonfield prepares to welcome its newest bagel destination this spring.
Follow Us!