PENNSVILLE, NJ – Italian Kitchen (339 N Hook Rd, Pennsville, NJ) is a place that proves there’s always room for discovery in the world of cheesesteaks. When I started my Philadelphia Cheesesteak Adventure, I heard the usual naysayers: “Everyone knows where to get a good cheesesteak!” and “How different can they be?” But my visit to Italian Kitchen – and the reaction to the photos I posted – showed just how wrong those assumptions can be. This South Jersey spot is serving up a cheesesteak that’s visually stunning and surprisingly delicious.
Italian Kitchen: A Pennsville Cheesesteak That Turns Heads (and Deserves More Cheese!)
A Cheesesteak That Demands Attention:
The first thing that strikes you about Italian Kitchen’s cheesesteak is its appearance. This is a good-looking sandwich that makes you stop and take a picture before you even take a bite. The online reaction to my photos confirmed this – people were impressed.
The Breakdown:
- Flavorful Meat: The meat had a “lot of flavor.”
- The Cheese: While the flavor was there, the quantity was lacking. This seems to be a recurring theme in my reviews – a great cheesesteak needs that perfect balance of meat and cheese, and Italian Kitchen could benefit from a more generous hand with the cheese.
- Free Fries!: My visit coincided with a “free french fries with every cheesesteak” day, a welcome bonus. And these weren’t just any fries; they were “perfect,” adding extra value to the meal.
Beyond the Cheesesteak:
The homemade treats.
Overall:
Italian Kitchen serves a cheesesteak that’s visually appealing and packed with flavor. The meat stands out, and the free fries are a welcome bonus. While I’d love to see more cheese on the sandwich, this is a minor quibble. Italian Kitchen is a prime example of why it’s worth exploring beyond the usual suspects – you never know when you’ll stumble upon a hidden gem that changes your perspective on what a cheesesteak can be.
Rating: 4.25 out of 5 stars (A delicious cheesesteak with excellent meat, held back slightly by the cheese quantity.)
Recommendations:
- To Diners: Try Italian Kitchen, especially if you’re looking for a cheesesteak that’s below average.
- To Italian Kitchen: Don’t be shy with the cheese! A more generous helping would elevate this already good cheesesteak to greatness.
Address:
Italian Kitchen 339 N Hook Rd Pennsville, NJ
Review by Jim Pappas, Philadelphia Cheesesteak Adventure
Follow Us!