Mama’s Pizzeria: Best Cheesesteak in Bala Cynwyd

PHILADELPHIA – Mama’s Pizzeria (426 Belmont Ave, Bala Cynwyd, PA) delivers a cheesesteak experience about abundance. This isn’t a delicate, nuanced sandwich; it’s a hefty, flavor-packed cheesesteak that leans heavily on its cheese and meat. As part of the ongoing Philadelphia Cheesesteak Adventure, this stop revealed a cheesesteak not for the faint of heart (or stomach).


The Cheesesteak Breakdown

  • Three-Legged Stool: The reviewer uses the analogy of a three-legged stool (roll, meat, cheese) to describe a good cheesesteak, and Mama’s has three good legs.
  • The Cheese: The cheese is a defining characteristic. Described as a “three-cheese blend” and “heavy,” cheese lovers will be in their element. The sheer quantity of cheese is a significant factor here.
  • The Meat: The meat is described as “juicy,” a positive attribute that suggests proper cooking and good quality beef.
  • The Roll: The roll isn’t explicitly mentioned, which, in the context of a cheesesteak review, often implies it’s at least adequate – it’s doing its job of holding everything together, but it’s not a standout feature.
  • The Combination: The reviewer suggests that the “powerful” combination of meat and cheese might be even better suited to an egg roll. This implies that the overall cheesesteak might be slightly unbalanced, with the cheese and meat overwhelming the other components.

Overall:

Mama’s Pizzeria serves a cheesesteak that’s undeniably heavy on the cheese and features juicy, flavorful meat. This cheesesteak is for those who prioritize quantity and a rich, cheesy experience. While the reviewer doesn’t explicitly mention the onions (or lack thereof), the focus is clearly on the meat and cheese. The suggestion of an egg roll pairing further emphasizes the richness of the filling.

Rating: (Based on the description, a 3.75-4.25 out of 5 stars seems appropriate. It’s a perfect cheesesteak, but the heaviness and potential imbalance might not appeal to everyone.)

Recommendations:

  • To Diners: Mama’s is worth a try if you love cheese and a substantial, filling cheesesteak. Be prepared for a rich and potentially overwhelming experience.
  • To Mama’s: (This is more speculative, as it’s based on a single review) Consider offering a “light cheese” option for those who prefer a more balanced cheesesteak.

Address: Mama’s Pizzeria 426 Belmont Ave Bala Cynwyd, PA

Review by Jim Pappas, Philadelphia Cheesesteak Adventure