Sully’s Irish Pub in Middletown, Delaware (12 W Main St) offers a unique dining experience steeped in history. The establishment claims that Thomas Jefferson and George Washington once dined within its walls, lending a certain gravitas to the atmosphere.
The Good:
- Historical Significance: The historical connection to such prominent figures in American history is a definite draw. It adds a layer of interest to the meal.
- House-Made Hot Peppers: These were a standout. Even for someone who isn’t typically a fan of hot peppers, Sully’s homemade version offers a noteworthy flavor. They’re a must-try for those who enjoy a bit of heat.
- Beer Cheese: The idea of a beer cheese is excellent.
The Mixed:
- The Cheesesteak Itself: While the concept of a beer cheese cheesesteak is appealing, the execution, in my experience, was somewhat lacking. The primary issue was the quantity of beer cheese; it needed a more generous application to fully deliver its promise. The base cheesesteak was decent but didn’t stand out as exceptional.
Overall:
Sully’s Irish Pub offers a unique draw with its historical claims. The house-made hot peppers were a surprising highlight. However, while decent, the cheesesteak didn’t quite live up to the potential of its ingredients, particularly the beer cheese. The cheesesteak could be significantly improved with a bit more generosity with that key ingredient.
Rating: 3.5 out of 5 stars
Recommendations:
- To Sully’s: Be more liberal with the beer cheese on the cheesesteak!
- To Diners: If you’re a history enthusiast, Sully’s is worth a visit for the atmosphere. If you’re primarily seeking a top-tier cheesesteak, you might want to temper your expectations, but the hot peppers are worth trying.
Address: Sully’s Irish Pub 12 W Main St Middletown, DE
Follow Us!